The Safe, or Simple Agreement for Future Equity, has become the dominant instrument for early-stage startup funding. The Safe, created and made popular by Y Combinator, allows start-ups to raise capital without issuing equity immediately. Investors get a right to convert their Safe into equity when the Company raises a larger, more-formal priced-equity round in the future. (Hence the name.) Safe holders receive whatever equity is being issued in the priced round—typically preferred stock.
For a broad introduction to Safes, take a look at our previous post here.
Safes were designed to be straightforward and inexpensive. Much cheaper than a traditional priced equity round in which all the details of equity ownership are negotiated. That’s accomplished by deferring those negotiations to the future round. The Safe essentially piggybacks on the terms of the next round.
But there are still a few things that need to be negotiated with a Safe. And in this article we’ll discuss what those are and what to keep in mind.
Valuation Caps
A valuation cap sets the maximum company valuation at which a Safe will convert regardless of the actual valuation that new investors use to price the future equity round. The lower the cap, the lower the price per share the Safe holders “pay” (via conversion) in the next round, and therefore the more equity the Safe holders receive when their Safes convert.
Here’s how this works:
Let’s say an investor puts $100,000 in your company and gets a Safe with a valuation cap of $5,000,000. Later, your company raises a priced round at a pre-money valuation of $10,000,000.
To keep things easy, say you have 10,000,000 shares outstanding on a fully diluted basis before the raise, so the new investors are going to pay $1.00 per share. (Because you have a $10,000,000 company value that’s divided evenly between its 10,000,000 shares.) As part of that round, the Safe will convert into the same stock that the new investors are buying.
But the valuation cap means the Safe holders will be paying $0.50 per share instead of the full $1.00 paid by the new investors.
It sounds simple enough. Your company receives a cash infusion. The investor receives upside during a future round when their Safe converts.
But valuation caps come in two varieties: pre-money and post-money. The main difference is how the company’s value is calculated at conversion. Which one you choose can have a significant impact on your cap table as the company grows.
Pre-Money Valuation Caps
A pre-money valuation cap is the implied value of the company before any new investments are added. With pre-money caps, upon conversion the valuation is calculated excluding the shares that would be issued to the Safe holders themselves.
This means the more money raised during a Safe round, the greater dilution for founders and existing shareholders. But the exact amount of dilution is unknown until the next priced equity round.
In other words, it is unclear how much of your company you’ll give up to Safe investors until all Safes are converted when the priced round has closed.
Post-Money Valuation Caps
A post-money valuation cap, on the other hand, is the implied value of the company after the Safe round investments have been included. This means each investor knows exactly what percentage of the company they will own once their Safe converts.
For example, if you invest $100,000 at a $10,000,000 post-money cap, you know you own 1%. The number of other Safes issued before the priced round are irrelevant from your standpoint.
The post-money Safe provides clarity for founders and investors, since ownership percentages are locked in at the time of investment. But this means more dilution to founders if multiple post-money Safes are raised in a larger Safe round, even if the exact amount of dilution is known from the outset.
Founder Tradeoffs
Pre-money Safes give you flexibility. You can raise multiple notes before a priced round, without promising fixed ownership slices. But dilution is harder to predict. The final impact isn’t clear until the next round closes and each Safe converts.
Post-money Safes give certainty. Investors know exactly what they own, and you know what you’ve sold. It’s easier to model your cap table and communicate with future investors. But you lose flexibility, since each Safe claims a fixed portion of the company before the next financing round even begins.
Which to Choose?
If you want value flexibility and are comfortable with some uncertainty, a pre-money cap may be preferable. It can be founder-friendly early on since since investors at that stage often are comfortable with less precise ownership. But it’s critical to track how much you’re raising to avoid unexpected dilution.
If you want predictability, a post-money cap is preferable. It’s also what most sophisticated investors expect these days, for the same reason. It locks in ownership and makes your cap table easier to explain. If you choose this approach, try to raise all Safes in a single round to avoid stacking fixed ownership percentages that can quickly add up.
Choosing between pre-money and post-money valuation caps is a decision that will materially shape your company. Whatever approach you choose, ensure the Safe’s terms map to your your long-term goals, and protect your ownership as your company grows.